Comparison
Every archive has a floor, and you hit it sooner than expected
Repurposing tools mine recordings you already own. SendShort captions, reframes and covers them well. Extraction has a yield curve, and by month three you are posting what you rejected twice. Here is where the seam runs out, what a fresh take costs, and how Cutroom finishes one.

- the longest source Cutroom accepts
- 3 min
- one batch, one drafted cut
- 100 CR
- coverage ceiling at normal pace
- 45%
The first pass over a back catalogue is the cheapest creative anyone ever ships
Hours of recordings already paid for, already spoken, sitting on a drive doing nothing.
Captioning, reframing and coverage happen automatically. Each recording becomes several posts and nobody films.
The cost per posted asset is the argument. The recording is bought, so every extra clip lowers the average again.
It removes a dependency on anybody being available, which is what usually breaks a posting schedule.
So the first pass goes to the clipper outright. The question is what happens on the third.
Extraction has a yield curve. The best four moments come out immediately and never come out again.
Cutroom does not mine anything. Forty seconds filmed this afternoon goes in instead.
Back comes a finished 9:16 MP4, captions burned in and coverage sitting on the words you marked.
The good moments come out first, and month three is scraping
By the third pass you are posting material you rejected twice. The audience notices that before you do.
There is an audience-side version of the decline. Repeated angles from one recording read as one idea told four ways.
Fatigue is not a feeling here. It is the same claim arriving again in different clothes.
There is a second limit that never goes away. The archive holds what you said, not what you should have said.
New offer. New objection. New competitor. New season. None of those exist in a recording from last year.
At that point the constraint is supply of new speaking. Forty seconds on a phone fixes it.
That take becomes an ad here for a 100-credit batch and 20 credits a finished minute.
The seam resets the moment somebody says the missing sentence out loud.
One afternoon of filming produces material the archive was never going to hold, and it produces it again next month.
Usable clips per pass over the same archive
Extraction has a yield curve. Filming a new take resets it, and a fresh take costs one 100-credit batch.
- First passAbout 12
- Second passAbout 5
- Third passAbout 2
This is the whole editor
Highlight a phrase and a clip lands on those exact words. No timeline, no keyframes, no layers.
Film the missing sentence, mark it, export it
Upload one take of up to three minutes. It returns transcribed, drafted into a full cut, and captioned as a 9:16 MP4.
Highlight a phrase and a clip lands over exactly those words. Swap it, or search millions of free ones.
Delete a line and the cut rebuilds around the gap. Change the pace and the whole piece re-cuts.
Emphasise the word your claim turns on so it pops in the captions. Fix a mis-heard word and the text follows.
Write the opening headline or take the drafted one, then export at 20 credits a finished minute.
No timeline, no keyframes, no layers. Eleven marks, all of them on the words.
Coverage is capped by pace: 40 percent on chill, 45 on normal, 52 on fast. A person stays at the centre of the ad.
Trim the opening or the ending. Choose how each clip enters: cut, whip, punch, glitch or sweep.
- Six caption packs, adjustable for colour, weight, size and position
- Coverage capped at 40, 45 or 52 percent depending on pace
- A second export from the same take does not re-charge the batch
- Somebody has to be on camera, or own a photo the avatar module can drive
One fresh take in, one finished ad out: the specification
It takes one talking-head take of up to three minutes. The ceiling is enforced at upload.
It returns a 9:16 MP4 with captions burned in and coverage already placed.
There is no landscape-to-vertical reframing and no speaker tracking. Film vertical.
There is no batch mode producing several clips from one file, and no ranking of what to post first.
There is one speaker per take, so recorded conversations are outside this.
There is no timeline, no version history, no scheduler, and nothing of yours is stamped on the file.
Those are the facts to plan around. The number they do not touch is attempts, which is next.
Mine while it yields. Film the month it stops.
Clipping covers reach cheaply while the archive holds. Filming covers the claims it never contained.
Winners run at 5 to 8 percent of creatives, per Motion's analysis of 550,000+ Meta ads. One in thirteen to one in twenty.
Six creatives a month draws under one winner, mined or recorded.
A second cut from a take already transcribed is 20 credits a minute and about four minutes.
So the claim you were unsure about gets filmed anyway. That is the behaviour that moves the number.
One finished minute from a fresh take is about 120 credits. Seven days and 300 credits with no card covers two.
Film the two sentences your archive never held, and find out cheaply whether the shortage was tooling or supply.
SendShort and Cutroom, row by row
The top two rows go to SendShort, and a yielding archive should weigh them heavily. The rest is what the seam cannot produce.
| SendShort | Cutroom | |
|---|---|---|
| Long recordings as input | Hours at a time | 3 minutes maximum |
| Reframing, and no new filming | The archive is the input | Somebody records vertical |
| Pace change re-cuts everything | The recording sets the pace | Chill, normal or fast |
| Music generated under the read | Bring your own track | Described style, 20 CR |
| A claim never spoken before | Bounded by the archive | Film it this afternoon |
| Coverage on a marked phrase | Automatic placement | Highlight, clip lands there |
| Cut rebuilds when a line goes | Trim it yourself | Delete, and it recompiles |
Questions people ask
- Can I bring a clip from a repurposing tool into Cutroom?
- Yes, if it is one person talking and under three minutes. It gets transcribed, drafted and captioned like any take, and you direct the cut by marking the transcript.
- How do I know the archive has run dry?
- When the clips you are posting are ones you skipped in earlier passes, and when the offer or the objection you need to address was never recorded. Both are supply problems rather than tooling problems.
- What does a fresh take cost to turn into an ad?
- A 100-credit batch covers transcription, the director pass and the b-roll search. Export is 20 credits per finished minute, so a one-minute ad is about 120 credits from scratch.
- Who should walk away?
- Anyone on the first pass over a real archive. Mine it, the yield is at its best right now. Come back the week you start posting moments you skipped twice.
A seam runs out. Cutroom turns the sentence that was never recorded into a finished 9:16 ad, captions burned in and coverage on the claim.